New findings from a two-year study bring researchers closer to understanding why some people are more likely to lose money to financial fraud. The FINRA Investor Education Foundation (FINRA Foundation), Better Business Bureau (BBB) Institute for Marketplace Trust, and the University of Minnesota completed the study, Exposed to Scams: Can Challenging Consumers’ Beliefs Protect Them from Fraud?, in advance of World Investor Week, October 4-10, 2021.
Investigators found that the attitudes and beliefs shaping the ways study participants looked at the world—known as “mental frames”—may have influenced the way they reacted to scams.
Specifically, researchers propose that mental frames governing compliance, opportunity, intelligence, and order may have affected the way that interviewees interpreted what scammers told them. Individuals were more likely to lose money if they believed that:
- Authority should not be challenged.
- Financial opportunities are a zero-sum game with clear winners and losers.
- The world is organized in a way that rewards good people.
- Asking too many questions can make a person seem ignorant.
Study participants were identified from a pool of people who filed reports with BBB Scam Tracker℠, an online fraud reporting tool offered by the Better Business Bureau. Researchers from Metro Tribal, LLC, an ethnographic-based social insight firm, conducted in-depth interviews that yielded key insights.
The researchers spoke with 17 people who were targeted by scammers. In recorded interviews, some participants explained how scammers reached out with promises of easy money or lucrative investments. Others described receiving phone calls from fraudsters posing as IRS agents and demanding payment of back taxes. Researchers also interviewed two young men who worked from an overseas call center to defraud hundreds of people using the IRS scam. Details of their activities and tactics, described in their own words, are included in the report.
“Exposed to Scams is an important addition to BBB Institute’s library of fraud research, encouraging us to learn how our mental frames could potentially impact our scam risk,” said Mel Trumpower, executive director, BBB Institute for Marketplace Trust.
A related quantitative study, Exposed to Scams: What Separates Victims from Non-Victims?, was released in September 2019. These studies offer vital insights for policymakers, financial institutions, law enforcement officials, and others who seek to protect investors and the public from financial scams.
About the FINRA Investor Education Foundation
The FINRA Investor Education Foundation supports innovative research and educational projects that give underserved Americans the knowledge, skills, and tools to make sound financial decisions throughout life. For more information about FINRA Foundation initiatives, visit FINRAFoundation.org.
About the BBB Institute for Marketplace Trust
The BBB Institute for Marketplace Trust is the educational foundation of the Better Business Bureau (BBB). BBB Institute’s mission is to educate and protect consumers, promote best practices for businesses, and solve complex marketplace problems. The organization’s consumer educational programs are delivered by BBBs serving communities across North America. Learn more at BBBMarketplaceTrust.org.
About the University of Minnesota
The flagship of the University of Minnesota System, the Twin Cities campus is Minnesota’s only land-grant university and one of the most prestigious public research universities in the nation. The University of Minnesota prepares students to meet the great challenges facing the state of Minnesota, our nation, and our world. Faculty and students seek new knowledge that can change how we all work and live.
About Metro Tribal, LLC
Metro Tribal is a social insight and advisory firm that helps mission-driven, public-facing organizations succeed by connecting them with the lived experience of their stakeholders. The company is based in Charlottesville, Virginia. Learn more at metrotribal.com.